I first began listing items on Craigslist 3 years ago, in 2008. My first item up was an old Dell desktop (black) with a flatscreen monitor. It sold quickly. My second sale was just a few days later, a green mountain bike from Target that was snatched up less than 30 minutes after the listing went up. I’ve also sold a ping-pong table and circa-1990′s dining room set and given away a couch for free.
The worst experience I’ve had so far was when a potential buyer borrowed my cell phone and when he handed it back, it was coated in a generous helping of the sweat from his face. Um, yuck. My outlook is that things could’ve been worse, I suppose!
I’ve also had a little experience as a buyer on Craigslist. During my first (almost) buying experience I found a desk I knew was perfect for my office, and I emailed the seller telling her I would be in town and to please let me know when I could come by and pick it up. “In town” means Atlanta, from which I live a good 45 minutes away. She lived on the other side of Atlanta from me. She said I could pick it up around eight. Long story short, I ended up staying in Atlanta until around 11 pm, no desk. I went home defeated. And with callouses from wandering aimlessly around 16 acres of Ikea.
I don’t really have a ‘lessons learned’ to share with you from my failed Craigslist experience, although I would recommend setting up a time before you travel anywhere, and call the seller on the phone. Ask for a phone number over email if you have to. Also, if you email the seller, leave your phone number and name at the bottom, or chances are they will think you are a spammer and never return your message.
Another buyer-trick: turn on “show images” in the upper right hand corner of the Craigslist search bar. Here’s the search page without show images activated:

"Show Images" on Craigslist
And here’s the page with show images activated (it becomes ‘hide images’):

"Hide Images" on Craigslist
Ahh, isn’t that better? Now you can see the images’ thumbnails without clicking. You can also hover your mouse over the thumbnail to get this view, which enlarges the thumbnail for easier browsing:

Craigslist Image Thumbnail Blowup!
Craigslist was kind of a TOTAL drag before I found out about these features. Also remember that you can use standard search operators in the Craigslist search bar. Searching for:
chair -pink
will search for the word ‘chair’ but will eliminate any listings that contain the word ‘pink.’ Perfect for when you are bringing up one too many pink chairs. Ha.
As far as prices on Craigslist, know your budget, know the fair market value for new & used (just check online stores and your local resale shops). If prices seem high, you can ask the seller if you may make a lower offer, but don’t expect them to bring down the price. Some people are trying to offload items that are new from stores in your area. Keep in mind the hidden costs of buying new items in-stores such as tax, and online such as shipping, and shipping surcharges. All of these extra costs are generally eliminated with Craigslist shopping.
Final buying tips – bring cash, ask for an address and use Google Maps for directions, decide on a price before you get there (honor the seller’s price), BUT remember – you don’t have to buy if you don’t like what you see in person, ask for measurements & measure your vehicle/method of transportation, and take a friend with you to pick something up.
And remember, be a friendly Craigslister whether you are browsing, buying, or selling. Craigslist brings disparate people within communities together, and you are bound to meet interesting people. It can be quite an adventure and a lot of fun!
Next time: Selling on Craigslist: Tips & Tricks! Stay tuned.
Leave a Comment